Preference is given to rentals for the full summer season, to rentals of one month or longer, and to rentals of over 15 days. We are allowed to accept a limited number of rentals for less than 15 days. Preference is given to families, as EH Town law prohibits too many unrelated guests in one rental. Small groups of responsible adults will be considered on a case by case basis. Please inquire for more information.
|-||Nightly rate||Weekly rate||Monthly rate||Min. Stay||Change-over|
|Rate summary||$800 - $3,500||$6,500 - $17,000||$32,000||4 Nights||-|
|October 2023 01-Oct-2023 - 31-Oct-2023||$1,000||$1,500||$8,000||$32,000||4 Nights||-|
|Additional 2 Adults Fee||Info||$250||Daily|
|Additional Adult Fee||Info||$125||Daily|
|Checkout Cleaning Fee||Required||$250||One time|
|Cleaning Fee - Weekly||Info||$225||Weekly|
|Pet Fee||Info||$350||One time|
|Suffolk charges a 3% tax on rentals 30 days or les||Required||3%||One time|
Dana is a Montauk native and grew up around the corner. She met Jason in Breckenridge in 2001 and after traveling around and enjoying Breck winters, the two returned to Montauk permanently in 2013. They work full time at the family business in town. They bought and flipped a unit in Montauk Shores, and have now purchased this house. The pair's hard work along with Dana's love of home design brought their first property some recognition & a quick sale last summer.
Dana & Jason purchased this house in 2017
Why Dana chose Montauk: 21 Fenwick is around the corner from where Dana grew up and is one of the most convenient locations in town. You can get anywhere on back roads avoiding traffic, and its central location means everything is within 5 minutes of the house. On top of that, the property was so private! The medium sized house, large yard, and even larger wooded area screamed potential. Jason loves the woods & Dana loves the sun, so it was perfect for us both. We can walk to my mom's, sister's, and my best friend's house all in about 3 minutes! We spent all winter tirelessly renovating & any repeat tenant can expect even more upgrades as the years go by.
What makes this house unique: This home is located steps away from Dana's sister, Bri's house at 57 Fairlawn, The Shea's at 44 Fairlawn, and The Davis's at 48 Fairlawn. The Murtha house is across the golf course. Dana's father has a lakeside cottage at 2 S. Lake Dr. Also offered for rent in summer season, multiple family groups can coordinate their accommodations nearby. Contact us for more information.
The house had everything we needed and was super clean, comfy and really pretty. The backyard is incredible. Love the deck off the kitchen and outdoor shower was the nicest one I’ve seen. The host was really great, helpful and accommodating. Love this house.
Stayed July, 2021
Charming 3 bedroom with incredibly well stocked kitchen. I’ve never seen a kitchen with so many amenities. Perfect for us, because we cooked in several nights - especially with Covid.
Beautiful walk to the beach. Host was extremely attentive, although we really didn’t need anything - everything was available. All texts with stupid questions were answered immediately. You can tell that the owners care very much about this home- which has clearly been updated. Very comfortable. We really had everything we wanted, and probably more. I would definitely come back and highly recommend this home. And hosts are lovely, friendly, caring people. Could not have chosen a better place for our family.
And the beds are very very comfortable.
Stayed September, 2020
My family, myself and my pets stayed at this lovely modern farmhouse home that was clean, attention to details, stocked with anything you would need, close to everything and owners at your call with any questions! On arrival we were greeted by Dana who took the time to show us around her beautiful home and fill with all the information we needed to know. The online images of her home are great and helped us make our decision, if only they could capture the comfort you feel staying there :-). We loved every moment and were disappointed we couldn't stay another week because of course it was already booked, hopefully though we can return next year! Thank you so much Dana and Jason!
Stayed August, 2020
Stunning property, excellent location and attentive hosts are just a few things that made for a perfect Montauk getaway! No complaints whatsoever! The owners went above and beyond to make sure the house was stocked with everything you could need...and then some. Would absolutely recommend!
Stayed August, 2020
The house was a perfect getaway, located close to the beach and town! It had everything we needed and more for a fun and comfortable stay. Dana is great and we'd definitely come back!
Stayed July, 2020
A lovely, well maintained home in beautiful Montauk, with everything you need for a great stay.
Stayed May, 2019
Amazing property and Dana was helpful and kind. Highly recommend.
Stayed August, 2018
We just returned from a four night stay in this lovely Montauk home. My only complaint is that we didn’t stay longer. First, the host Dana was incredibly gracious with answering questions prior to booking. We scheduled this trip last minute and the host was responsive to each and every request for information. Upon arrival, which was seemless, host Jason arrived to greet us within two minutes of pulling into the driveway. Again,he was inviting and responsive to all questions. We had two dogs, two kids, my wife and I. The home was the perfect size. The outdoor area which includes a totally fenced-in backyard (perfect for dogs) contains a lovely outdoor shower, deck, grill, hammocks and seating area. There is a table to eat al fresco or inside weather depending. The kitchen was fully stocked with any items that you would need, including pots,pans, cutlery, ziplocks, foil, everything and anything! The washer/dryer was large and conveniently located in the basement of the home. The town of Montauk is a quick car-ride (2 minutes) or bike ride away. If you want to walk to town you can certainly do so if you are physically fit. There was ample free parking all over town including the beach which was beautiful. I highly recommend this property.
Stayed July, 2018
The beds and bedding were top shelf. The kitchen is stocked and accessorized better than our own kitchen. Loved it. Washer and dryer are huge and very beneficial. Lovely quiet neighborhood. Close to town and the beach. VERY dog friendly front porch, rear deck, and backyard. That was paramount for us. Owners are very attentive and instantly responsive to any questions. Great entertainment set up in living room and each of the bedrooms. Definite 5 star choice.
Stayed July, 2018
Dana and Jason were GREAT hosts! Their home was the perfect size for our group! Everything was clean and renovated recently. Kitchen was stunning, we cooked almost every night! They left all the linens we would need and were so helpful if we had any questions. BBQ was great and outdoor shower was so handy when we tanned in the yard. So much space we were able to set up some yard games and had a blast! Can’t wait to stay again next summer! THANKS AGAIN!
Stayed June, 2018