Fire Island Vacation Rentals

Only 5 houses from the ocean. Check out our reviews!!
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
House, Bedroom(s): 5, Sleeps: 10
All Rentals are for 6 nights 7 days. The last day is required for cleaning.
$650 - $950 /Night
Lovely Ocean Ridge A-Frame on National Seashore Boundary with ocean views
Long Island > Fire Island > Davis Park
House, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 8
House, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, (Sleeps 8)
$450 - $650 /Night
Beach Bungalow - Ocean Beach
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
House, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 12
New Listing! This upside down house is Family & Pet Friendly & many amenities
$499 - $1,999 /Night
OCEANFRONT Heaven!!!
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Bay Park
House, Bedroom(s): 5, Sleeps: 12
House, 5 Bedrooms, 2.5 Baths, (Sleeps 12)
$700 - $2,000 /Night
Beach Cottage with Hot Tub, Pool & Air Conditioning
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Bay Park
House, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 12
Beach Cottage with Hot Tub, Pool & Central Air-Condition. Location-Ocean Bay Park, close to everything; ferry, beach and convenience store, Schooners & Flynns.
$800 - $1,500 /Night
MAROONED! Fire Island! Great ocean views! Just steps to the beach!
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Bay Park
House, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 10
New modern beach house with grand ocean views. 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Baths, (Sleeps 10-12).
$1,000 - $1,750 /Night
Oceanfront Paradise in Robbins Rest
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
House, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 8
House, 4 Bedrooms, 1.5+ Baths, (Sleeps 8)
$700 - $1,500 /Night
Summer is coming! Book now! Steps from the ocean!
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Bay Park
House, Bedroom(s): 6, Sleeps: 12
House, 6 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, (Sleeps 12)
Fire Island Boatel
Long Island > Fire Island > Kismet
Studio, Sleeps: 4
The Fire Island Boatel is pleased to offer ten newly renovated suites on the shore of Kismet. https://fireislandboatel.lodgify.com/

OFFER Group discounts may be available for guests who are interested in reserving 3 or more suites. For more information regarding this discount, please contact the Fire Island Boatel for more information at (833) 342-6283 or fiboatel@gmail.com.

Special offer period: May 1, 2021 - Nov 15, 2021

TOP OF THE DUNES
Long Island > Fire Island > Lonelyville
House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 6
1200 SQFT OCEAN FRONT BEACH HOUSE. 6 GUEST MAX. 2 WEEK MINIMUM STAY. NOT SUITABLE FOR THE WHEELCHAIR BOUND OR SMALL CHILDREN. PETS ARE WELCOME.
$750 /Night

OFFER QUERY OWNER ABOUT MONTHLY RENTAL DISCOUNT.

Special offer period: Jun 1, 2021 - Jun 30, 2021

Ocean Bay Park Fire Island
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Bay Park
House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 10
3 Bedroom + Loft, 1.5 Bath Bungalow Close To The The Beach, Sleeps 10
$700 - $1,125 /Night
Oceanfront Beach House
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 6
House, 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, 6 Sleeps maximum
$600 - $972 /Night
A Scoop of Paradise - Ocean Beach Fire Island Rental
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
House, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 8
2 bedroom, 1 Bath, newly renovated with all new furnishings, HVAC, linen and towels!
$584 - $1,500 /Night
Charming Bay View Cottage
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 5
This fully renovated cottage is perfectly located just one house off the Great South Bay & only a 2 minute walk to town.
$325 - $560 /Night
Secluded, great bay views, great for families, close friends
Long Island > Fire Island > Kismet
House, Bedroom(s): 5, Sleeps: 12
2021 peak season weeks $6,400 less a possible 10% discount. Ask about it. Includes central A/C. Upscale and well-maintained, 5 bedrooms, 2.5 bath, TV's each rm.
$490 - $1,835 /Night
Salt water built in POOL!!! booking 2021
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
House, Bedroom(s): 5, Sleeps: 12
Relax and enjoy your stay in Ocean Beach, Fire Island! Beautiful private pool.
$1,000 - $2,000 /Night
Seas the Day! Enjoy Fire Island in Lux Comfort!
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Beach
House, Bedroom(s): 5, Sleeps: 12
A Luxe Summer Vacation Rental, nestled in the heart of Ocean Beach, FI. Come spend time at the beach with family and friends while you make life long memories!
$500 - $5,800 /Night
Beach House - Fire Island, NY
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Bay Park
House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 8
Beach House Contemporary 3 bedroom 2 bath, outdoor shower. Located between the Great South Bay and Atlantic Ocean (1) min to either Ocean or Bay.
$650 /Night
BOOK NOW! I PRIME Weeks, Weekends and mid weeks now AVAILABLE!!!This won't last!
Long Island > Fire Island > Kismet
House, Bedroom(s): 7, Sleeps: 24
A Magnificent house for Family reunions, Bachelorette Parties or large groups !!
Second House from the Beach
Long Island > Fire Island > Ocean Bay Park
House, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 8
Come put your feet in the sand in this adorable and beautifully located home steps from the beach.
$1,000 - $1,500 /Night