Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake

Cottage in Finger Lakes, Keuka Lake, Hammondsport
  • Sleeps
  • Bedroom(s)
  • Bathroom(s)
    1 full, 1 half
  • $300 - $500



This cozy and charming cottage is the perfect lakeside retreat. It's right on Keuka lake, has a gentle slope to the water with a beautiful view, and is located approximately 7 miles North of Hammondsport on the East side of Keuka Lake, near the town of Wayne. The cottage is in a quiet area, about ¼ mile off of the main road (Hwy 54). 

If Keuka Lake is the Jewel of the Finger Lakes, our cottage on Marilena Point is the choicest of gems you'll find right on the water! At first glance, you will no doubt understand why this charming and historic property has been cherished by the Shoemaker family since its construction in 1935.

At second glance, when you walk through the back door, you will fall in love! Amidst the 30's vintage architectural features and antique pieces of our cozy cottage, you will also discover all the necessary updates and comforts for modern-day living...baseboard heating, ceiling fans, thermal windows; stainless steel appliances, renovated main bathroom, new/renewed comfortable furniture throughout; well-maintained outdoor landscaping; sturdy and comfortable outdoor seating, whether on the covered side porch, wide open lawn, or over the water on our permanent dock.

To top it off, there is a large fire pit area at the water's edge for cozy evenings under the stars, while roasting marshmallows and having a chat. The "water's edge" is only 30 feet from the front door, with a very gentle slope into the water...just perfect for watching small children play in the shallows, sliding in your kayak and canoe, or launching your family's boat.

It goes without saying that Keuka Lake itself is an outdoor "recreation center," whether for boating, water skiing, jet skiing, tubing, swimming, kayaking, paddle boarding, canoeing, fishing, snorkeling, or numerous other lake-based activities...its gorgeous clean, clear, sparkling water is a draw without equal!

Within a short driving distance from the cottage is the village of Hammondsport to the South (voted "Coolest Small Town in America"), Penn Yan to the North, and Watkins Glen to the East. Keuka Lake State Park, Letchfield State Park, and Finger Lakes National Forest are all within a 60 mile radius of 9299 Spruce Road...breathtaking scenery, waterfalls, hiking, picnicking, and camping at your fingertips! Within a 20 mile radius are the Glenn H. Curtiss Museum, Champlin Beach, Depot Park, Finger Lakes Boating Museum, Watkins Glen State Park, Birdseye Hollow State Forest, Sugar Hill State Forest, and a large number of award-winning wineries including Dr. Konstantin Frank Wine Cellars, Heron Hill Winery, Rooster Hill Vineyards, and Weis Vineyards.

So much to see, so much to do. Come on in, get comfortable, put your feet up, relax and stay awhile! The Shoemakers are very glad to have you...Cheers!! 

Accommodation, Features

Property Type
Cottage, 2,000 sq. ft.
3 Bedroom(s), 8 Sleeps
King: 1
Queen: 1
Twin / Single: 4
1 Bathroom(s) (1 Half bathrooms)
Combination Tub / Shower: 2
Location Type
Lake View
Water View
Vacation Types
Away From It All
Lake Front
Pet Friendly
Sports & Activities
Tourist Attractions
Access & Parking
Parking for RV/Boat/Trailer
Parking Off Street
Satellite / Cable
Popular Amenities
Clothes Dryer
Dining Area
Linens Provided
Outdoor Grill
Towels Provided
Washing Machine
Wireless Internet
Indoor Features
Alarm Clock
Coffee Maker
Hair Dryer
Ice Maker
Iron & Board
Living Room
Pantry Items
Outdoor Features
Beach Chairs
Beach Umbrellas
Deck / Patio
Lawn / Garden
Outdoor Charcoal Grill
Outdoor Furniture
Picnic Table
Porch / Veranda
Water Sports Gear
Activities & Adventure
Fly Fishing
Freshwater Fishing
Jet Skiing
Sight Seeing
Water Skiing
Nearby Attractions
Churches (7 miles)
Marina (7 miles)
Museums (7 miles)
Restaurants (7 miles)
Winery Tours (2 miles)


July 2022
September 2022
October 2022
November 2022
December 2022
  • Not available
  • Pending
  • Available
  • No Rates Set


-Nightly rateWeekly rateMonthly rateMin. StayChange-over
Rate summary $300 - $500 $2,200 - $3,000 - 1 Nights -

Fees, Taxes, Deposit

TypeTypePriceCharge Type
CleaningRequired $30Daily


Check in: 02:00 / Check out: 10:00
No parties/events

No smoking

Pets allowed

Dogs only

Children allowed

Minimum age of primary renter:21

Max occupancy:8

No pets on furniture
Cancellation Policy
100% refund if canceled at least 60 days before arrival date. 50% refund if canceled at least 30 days before arrival date.
Pet Friendly: Some pets, please inquire
Smoking: No smoking
Children: Yes, great for kids
Long term rentals: No
Seniors: Not suitable
Wheelchair Accessible: No
Suitability Details
Dogs only

13 Reviews

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Great House, Fantastic Location

This house is great. The property is completely flat which is harder to find in the area. The back yard between the house and the water is large and our dogs loved it. It's located just a few minutes outside of the center of Hammondsport and very close to great wineries. We stayed in October and this house was perfect for the weather we had (though I imagine it would be amazing in the summer too). We enjoyed the firepit outside and the fireplace inside daily. The owner, Craig, was very responsive for any question that we had and even when we "accidentially" locked ourselves out of the house one night, he stayed on the phone with us until we were able to get back in. I highly recommend this house to anyone from a couple to a large group! Also they're super dog friendly, to the point that there is a chest upstairs full of dog towels and dog sheets! A+

Stayed October, 2019

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Fantastic cottage experience! On a beautiful lake!

Great location! Top notch owner! Great vacation experience every year! Been going here since I was a kid! Owner is always making improvements! Caught a ton of perch and some LM Bass off the dock this year too! The whole family loves it! Amazing views in all directions!

Stayed June, 2019

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Lake comfort

What a terrific place to stay! Despite poor weather, the cottage was very comfortable and lacked nothing. We will definitely stay again!

Stayed May, 2019

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Cozy romantic getaway

Wonderfully quiet cottage perfect for a relaxing weekend away. We loved it!

Stayed December, 2018

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Our second stay!

We came back to this gem for Memorial Day after a stay in November! Since the weather was so much warmer, we were able to enjoy so much more! The side porch was perfect, light breezes and shade. We had a few nights sitting on the dock as well. Of course, our dog enjoy her swims several times a day! The owners were very nice and attended to any concerns or questions we had. I believe we will be making this home a regular vacation spot for years to come!

Stayed May, 2018

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Lovely stay right on the water

We had a lovely stay at this cottage that you could tell had a lot of history and love there from its family owners over generations!
The kitchen isn't huge but is very well-appointed. The downstairs 1/2 bathroom is tiny but does the job. Overall, the cottage was clean and cozy.
The only small suggestions I would give are these: In the downstairs queen bedroom, there is a top/bottom washer and dryer in the middle of the room; finding a different place for it would be ideal (if possible). Also, the bed metal bed frame in that room was poking out significantly, so we needed to put a pillow in front of it so we wouldn't bump our leg into it.
We had a wonderful and comfortable stay! The upstairs main bedroom had a really comfortable bed, and the upstairs bathroom was large and clean. They had clean linens, towels, and a first-aid kit at the ready. Lots of windows allowed for nice natural light and a lovely cross-breeze of the lake air. There is a convenient lakeside market named "The Olney Place Market & Deli" a few miles up the road, and the location is ideal, right on the lake. We wouldn't hesitate to book it again!

Stayed May, 2018

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Beautiful cottage

Even though it snowed for 3 days while we stayed, it was still a grand time and a superb visit all around! It's correct that this is the best location on the lake!

Stayed April, 2018

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Great cozy cabin by the lake!

Went for a NYE getaway, and it was perfect. Nice quiet place, cozy atmosphere and all the modern convenieces one needs. Definitely looking forward to coming here again.

Stayed December, 2017

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Everything was wonderful.

We enjoyed the spaciousness of the porch and of course the fireplace.
The kitchen was functional and the knives were sharp!

Stayed December, 2017

Charming Lakefront Cottage - Most Desirable Location on Keuka Lake
Thanksgiving gathering

All 6 of us were comfortable and cozy in this cottage. The kitchen had everything we needed to cook our feast and relax at the table enjoying our beautiful lake view. The bedrooms were comfortable, and the wi-if and tv worked great, though we spent most of our time touring the area and playing games. We were blessed with decent weather, and got to enjoy the outdoors quite a bit. It will be a memorable thanksgiving for all of us. Also the owner was very easy to work with.

Stayed November, 2017

14477 View(s) Last update: 18-Apr-2022 16:56

Contact the Owner

Your Information

Tell us about your trip:

If your dates are flexible select approximate travel dates to help speed up the process.

Message to owner:

Fields marked with * are mandatory
$300 - $500 $2,200 - $3,000
Select Dates for an Instant Quote
and Request to Book Online

Booking request