Cayuga Lake Vacation Rentals

Sunrise Cottage - Cayuga Lake Waterfront Retreat - Sleeps 6+
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake > Seneca Falls
House, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 6
Charming, year-round waterfront cottage on the western shore of Cayuga Lake offers an oasis to unwind, relax, and enjoy lake life.
$385 - $495 /Night
The Tate House, Historical and Spacious, 5 miles to downtown
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake > Ithaca
House, Bedroom(s): 5, Sleeps: 12
Just a 5-mile drive or Uber to downtown Ithaca.
$590 /Night
Sunset House on Cayuga
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake > Aurora
House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 6
ON THE WATER 10 MILE VIEW FROM WRAP AROUND DECK - YEAR ROUND TASTEFULLY FURNISHED private home - 1 mile south Aurora NY- Boat lift availability negotiable
$295 /Night
Spectular view of lake..Pet friendly..Lake Front House with Cottage
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake
Cottage, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 8
150 feet lake front 4 Bedrooms 3 full baths & 1 1/2 Baths, (Sleeps 8);
$400 - $582 /Night
Sweetgrass Cottage: Walk to Sheldrake Point Winery, Beach and Boat Launch
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake
Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 6
A private country cottage above Sheldrake Creek features open floor plan, 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths and a loft.
$190 - $195 /Night
HUGE New House On Private Acreage In Ithaca ~ Hot Tub ~ Private Pond
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake > Ithaca
House, Bedroom(s): 6, Sleeps: 12
6BR/6BA rental for up to 12 guests, close to wineries, state parks and lakes
$900 - $1,200 /Night
Judy's Guest House
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake > Trumansburg
House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 5
Country House, 3 Bedrooms, Direct TV in all bedrooms and living room, Sleeps 5, lots of room inside and out.
Upstate NY Cayuga Lakefront Camp
Finger Lakes > Cayuga Lake > Ithaca
House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 6
3BR, 2BA Cayuga Lake house about 15 minutes from Cornell/Ithaca.
$350 - $1,000 /Night

Cayuga Lake Vacation Rental & Travel Guide

  Cayuga Lake Vacation and Cabin Rentals   What are the most popular destinations to visit in Finger Lakes? Cayuga Lake is located in the Finger Lakes region of New York State. At just under 40 miles long with an average width of 1.7 miles, it is the longest of all the eleven Finger Lakes. As one of the top vacation destinations in New York, the Finger Lakes, especially Cayuga Lake, offers something for everyone.

Cayuga Lake is a quaint vacation destination that offers fantastic hiking trails, stunning views, and fun! You’ll find great local wineries like Cayuga Ridge Estate , Montezuma Winery , Varick Winery & Vineyard , and Six Mile Creek Vineyard . In total, wineries along the Cayuga Lake wine trail have captured over 6,000 national and international medals so you won’t be disappointed.

Aside from being one of the top... Read more
Cayuga, NY, USA