Keuka Lake Vacation Rentals

Escape to a private, Finger Lakes cottage tucked into a wooded lot beside a peaceful babbling brook.

Escape to our recently renovated waterfront cottage in the heart of the wine trail.

The Sunflower cottage is centrally located to wineries, Keuka and Seneca lakes, and other attractions.

Escape to our restored 1850s farmhouse, an authentic Finger Lakes retreat centered around an iconic red barn featuring a one-of-a-kind hot tub inside.

"Serenity on The Bluff" is a spectacular home for your next family vacation/reunion/anniversary or get away weekend. No booking fee on Newyorkrentalbyowner.com!

Quiet Lakeside Cottage on Keuka Lake

Charming, light-filled cottage on beautiful Keuka Lake! Take in the beautiful surroundings on your large front porch or hop down to the dock and enjoy the lake.

2 bedroom cottage on the water on beautiful Keuka Lake located 1 mile South of Keuka College on the East Bluff Drive.

A Modern year-round haven of luxury, with wine and craft beverage tastings, tours, and outdoor recreation included at one simple price, no hidden fees.

Fall in love with Keuka at Keuka Kara.

Amazing Keuka lakefront views!

Keuka Lake Listing on Desirable East Bluff Dr. 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath sleeps 10.

Completely rebuilt home. Sleeps 8. Drive Down, walk out to level yard and beach. Permanent dock to bring your boat. Rent Sunday to Sunday

Waterfront Property w/amazing views & plenty of space for multiple families 2 Houses included in this rental 5bedroom main house and 3 bedroom cottage

House, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Baths, 8 Sleeps

Hall's Grape Escape - 2 BR, 1 Bath updated cottage sleeps 4 with 50 feet of water frontage. Perfect for small families or couples.

Lakefront retreat on Waneta: private beach, sauna, game room, fire pit & king suite. Perfect for families, friends & dogs to relax, play & unwind.

4 Bedrooms, 1 Full bath plus an outdoor shower, Sleeps 8, waterfront

3 bedroom, 2 bath, open, clean lake house. Sleeps 8. Great for families with private beach, beautiful sunrises and just relaxing

Spacious lakefront home on Keuka Lake with private beach, dock, kayaks, and stunning sunset views—perfect for families and group getaways.