Finger Lakes Vacation Rentals

Filter List View Map View Availability

FEATURED

Private Country House, Garden, Big Yard, Full Kitchen, on Wine Trail

Finger Lakes > Seneca Lake > Himrod

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 6

A relaxing country stay, with all you'll really need to enjoy your time away from home.

ID#: 1159 | Last update: 09-Jun-2026 | 546 View(s)

$255 - $290 /Night

24 Reviews

Arrowhead Beach-Seneca Waterfront-Hot Tub-Sunrise-Covered Deck-Pets OK

Finger Lakes > Seneca Lake > Dresden

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 6

Escape to our peaceful waterfront retreat on Seneca Lake! This inviting getaway for up to 6 guests offers stunning lake views, a private hot tub & a fenced yard

ID#: 624 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 21751 View(s)

$135 - $399 /Night

10 Reviews

The Cottage at Poplar Cove-Fully Loaded! 108' Lakefront, Kayaks, & the BEST Sunset Views

Finger Lakes > Owasco Lake > Auburn

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 8

2BR (5 Beds)/ 2BA, Sleeps 8. 108' of private, level lakefront, 2.5 acres of grassy yard, panoramic windows, and kayaks.

ID#: 717 | Last update: 13-Feb-2025 | 13696 View(s)

$470 - $700 /Night

41 Reviews

Morning Dove-Secluded Cottage-Hot Tub-Pets OK-Scenic Wooded Lot

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake > Penn Yan

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 8

Escape to a private, Finger Lakes cottage tucked into a wooded lot beside a peaceful babbling brook.

ID#: 630 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 10289 View(s)

$125 - $399 /Night

10 Reviews

Fully Loaded! 5 Star! Modern and Remodeled! Lakefront!

Finger Lakes > Owasco Lake > Auburn

House, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 8

4BR 2BA modern lakefront home with over 60ft of private lakefront - modernized for your whole family! Standout property with high end finishes!

ID#: 1039 | Last update: 14-Jun-2025 | 3730 View(s)

10 Reviews

Renovated Lake Retreat w Hot Tub + Covered Dock & Big Deck - Pets OK

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake > Penn Yan

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 6

Escape to our recently renovated waterfront cottage in the heart of the wine trail.

ID#: 628 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 24018 View(s)

$135 - $399 /Night

50 Reviews

Seneca LakeHeart of Wine TrailHot Tub6 Private & Scenic AcresPets

Finger Lakes > Seneca Lake > Himrod

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 8

n/a

ID#: 629 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 10589 View(s)

$179 - $399 /Night

10 Reviews

Lake Dreamin-Seneca-100ft Private Level Beach-Hot Tub-Pets OK

Finger Lakes > Seneca Lake > Dresden

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 6

Escape to our private Seneca Lake cottage for 6! Set on nearly an acre, this secluded retreat features over 100 ft of rare, grassy, level lake frontage.

ID#: 626 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 17363 View(s)

$135 - $399 /Night

46 Reviews

Sunflower-KeukaSeneca-Lake View-Hot Tub-Wine Trail-Pets, 13 Wooded Acres-7 min to Beach

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake > Penn Yan

House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 8

The Sunflower cottage is centrally located to wineries, Keuka and Seneca lakes, and other attractions.

ID#: 631 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 18051 View(s)

$179 - $399 /Night

42 Reviews

Authentic 1850s Finger Lakes Farmhouse w Barn Hot Tub-Big Rooms-Seneca-Keuka-Pets OK

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake > Penn Yan

Farmhouse, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 8

Escape to our restored 1850s farmhouse, an authentic Finger Lakes retreat centered around an iconic red barn featuring a one-of-a-kind hot tub inside.

ID#: 749 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 7108 View(s)

$125 - $499 /Night

9 Reviews

Wildflower-Seneca Lake-Water View-Hot Tub-Acre of Privacy-Pets OK

Finger Lakes > Seneca Lake > Dresden

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 4

Tucked away on a scenic acre overlooking Seneca Lake, The Wild Flower is a cozy, redecorated cottage designed for a peaceful Finger Lakes escape.

ID#: 627 | Last update: 13-Apr-2026 | 12499 View(s)

$139 - $319 /Night

38 Reviews

Lakefront Oak Cottage • Hot Tub & Fire Pit

Finger Lakes > Sodus Bay > Sodus Point

House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 10

-Hot Tub -Direct Lakefront -3 Bedrooms,3 Bath, Sleeps 10 -Fire Pit -Full kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, smart TV, indoor fireplace -Free Parking -Located in a State Park

ID#: 1070 | Last update: 16-Jul-2026 | 4297 View(s)

$200 - $530 /Night

26 Reviews

Lakefront Pine Cottage • Hot Tub & Fire Pit

Finger Lakes > Sodus Bay > Sodus Point

House, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 10

-Hot Tub -Direct Lakefront -3 Bedrooms,2 Bath, Sleeps 10 -Fire Pit -Full kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, smart TV, indoor fireplace -Free Parking -Located in a State Park

ID#: 392 | Last update: 13-Feb-2026 | 35353 View(s)

$160 - $500 /Night

41 Reviews

Cozy Cottage • Lake Access • Fire Pit

Finger Lakes > Sodus Bay

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 5

- Fully equipped kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, and Smart TV - Lake Access - Free parking on site - Fire Pit - Located in a State Park!

ID#: 981 | Last update: 13-Feb-2026 | 4016 View(s)

$140 - $350 /Night

29 Reviews

Spectacular Lake Front Home, Jetted Hot Tub, Cent Air Con and Fire Pit. Aval 8-16 to 9-9 -

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake > Keuka Park

House, Bedroom(s): 6, Sleeps: 20

"Serenity on The Bluff" is a spectacular home for your next family vacation/reunion/anniversary or get away weekend. No booking fee on Newyorkrentalbyowner.com!

ID#: 82 | Last update: 21-Jul-2026 | 53616 View(s)

$595 - $895 /Night

17 Reviews

O'Cottage, Keuka Lake Vacation Rental with 150 feet of private lake front

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake > Keuka Park

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 12

Private, quiet, renovated home on 150 feet of lake frontage located at end of East Bluff Drive. Four bedrooms, two bathrooms; sleeps 12.

ID#: 10 | Last update: 21-Feb-2025 | 66691 View(s)

$495 - $995 /Night

33 Reviews

Quiet Lakeside Cottage

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 4, Sleeps: 8

Quiet Lakeside Cottage on Keuka Lake

ID#: 571 | Last update: 06-Jan-2025 | 21997 View(s)

$300 - $515 /Night

0 Reviews

Lovely Waterfront Cottage on Keuka

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 8

Charming, light-filled cottage on beautiful Keuka Lake! Take in the beautiful surroundings on your large front porch or hop down to the dock and enjoy the lake.

ID#: 570 | Last update: 01-Feb-2025 | 33392 View(s)

$270 - $470 /Night

7 Reviews

Keuka Belle on Keuka Lake

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake > Penn Yan

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 2, Sleeps: 7

2 bedroom cottage on the water on beautiful Keuka Lake located 1 mile South of Keuka College on the East Bluff Drive.

ID#: 111 | Last update: 11-Feb-2026 | 29195 View(s)

$214.29 /Night

0 Reviews

Our Point of View

Finger Lakes > Keuka Lake

Cottage, Bedroom(s): 3, Sleeps: 6

Beautiful lakefront prop perfectly located 1/2 way down east lake with flat lakefront,amazing sunsets, view of the lake and bluff. Brand new Kitchen and bath.

ID#: 997 | Last update: 06-May-2026 | 6164 View(s)

$275 - $595 /Night

9 Reviews

Discover and Explore The Finger Lakes

Finger Lakes Vacation and Cabin Rentals Imagine seeing beautiful views of sparkling water or vineyards just outside your window. Enjoy your morning coffee on a private deck, surrounded by the sounds of nature, or take a leisurely stroll through charming villages filled with small shops and restaurants offering fresh, local food.

All this becomes possible when you choose one of the many Finger Lakes vacation rentals in the heart of the Finger Lakes . Whether it's a cozy Finger Lakes cottage by the lake view or a luxurious Finger Lakes cabin tucked away in the woods, these accommodations offer comfort and convenience, often being pet friendly and opening doors to authentic experiences that will stay with you. So get ready for an unforgettable adventure as we explore what makes the Finger Lakes premier properties a captivating destination or Finger Lakes vacation... Read more

Ithaca, NY, USA